Kendamil vs Nannycare: Which Goat Milk Formula Is Right for Your Baby?
Goat milk formula has surged in popularity among UK parents looking for a gentler alternative to standard cow's milk formula. Two brands dominate the conversation: Kendamil Goat and Nannycare. Both are made in the UK, both use goat milk as their base — but they are quite different products. This guide breaks down everything you need to know so you can make a confident, informed choice for your baby.
🛒 Ready to shop? Browse our UK-stocked ranges:
- → Shop Kendamil Formula (all variants including Goat)
- → Shop Nannycare Goat Milk Formula (Stage 1, 2 & 3)
Quick Comparison: Kendamil Goat vs Nannycare at a Glance
| Feature | Kendamil Goat | Nannycare |
|---|---|---|
| Milk source | Whole goat milk | Goat milk |
| Stages available | Stage 1, 2 & 3 | Stage 1, 2 & 3 |
| Palm oil free | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| No added maltodextrin | ✅ Yes | ❌ Contains maltodextrin |
| DHA/ARA | ✅ Fish oil-derived | ✅ Present |
| Made in | UK (Cornwall) | New Zealand (NZ goat milk) |
| Organic option | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
About Kendamil Goat Formula
Kendamil is a British brand based in the Lake District. Their Goat formula is made with whole goat milk — meaning the full fat content of the milk is retained, which more closely mirrors the fat profile of breast milk. Kendamil prides itself on being palm oil-free, free from maltodextrin, and adding DHA from sustainable marine sources rather than synthetic algae oil.
Kendamil Goat is available in three stages:
- Stage 1 (0–6 months) – for newborns and young infants
- Stage 2 (6–12 months) – follow-on milk
- Stage 3 (1–3 years) – toddler milk
For parents who also want an organic option, Kendamil Organic (cow's milk) is also available in our store. Many parents use Kendamil Goat when their baby shows sensitivity to standard cow's milk formula.
→ Browse all Kendamil formulas in our UK store
About Nannycare Formula
Nannycare has been a trusted goat milk formula brand in the UK for over 30 years. Their formula is made from New Zealand goat milk, sourced from free-range goats in a country renowned for its dairy standards. Nannycare is free from artificial preservatives and colours, and like Kendamil Goat, is palm oil-free.
One key difference: Nannycare does contain maltodextrin as a carbohydrate source, whereas Kendamil Goat does not. Some parents prefer to avoid maltodextrin, particularly if they are following a closer-to-nature feeding philosophy.
Nannycare is also available in three stages, covering birth through toddlerhood.
→ Browse all Nannycare formula (Stage 1, 2 & 3)
Why Choose Goat Milk Formula in the First Place?
Goat milk has a naturally different protein structure to cow's milk. The casein proteins in goat milk form a softer curd in the stomach, which many parents find easier for their baby to digest. Goat milk also has a slightly different fatty acid profile. It is important to note, however, that goat milk formula is not recommended as a treatment for cow's milk protein allergy (CMPA) — for diagnosed CMPA, your GP or paediatrician will prescribe a specialist formula.
That said, many parents whose babies seem gassy, uncomfortable, or unsettled on cow's milk formula find that switching to a goat milk option makes a noticeable difference. Always consult your health visitor or GP before switching formula.
Kendamil vs Nannycare: Key Differences Explained
1. Whole Milk vs Skimmed Milk
Kendamil uses whole goat milk, retaining the full natural fat content. Nannycare uses a combination of skimmed goat milk and added vegetable oils to achieve the required fat content. Neither approach is wrong, but parents who prefer a less processed fat profile tend to lean towards Kendamil.
2. Maltodextrin
Kendamil Goat does not contain maltodextrin — it uses lactose as its primary carbohydrate, just like breast milk. Nannycare contains maltodextrin alongside lactose. Maltodextrin is a common, safe food ingredient, but some parents prefer to avoid it.
3. Origin of the Goat Milk
Kendamil sources its goat milk from UK farms. Nannycare sources its goat milk from New Zealand. Both are reputable origins — this is largely a personal or values-based preference.
4. Organic Option
Only Kendamil offers an organic goat milk formula variant. If organic certification matters to you, Kendamil Goat is the clear choice.
5. Taste and Palatability
Goat milk formula has a slightly more distinct taste than cow's milk formula. Both Kendamil Goat and Nannycare have the characteristic mild goaty flavour. Most babies adapt quickly. If your baby is transitioning from another brand, you may wish to mix the new formula gradually over several days.
Which Should You Choose?
Here's our simple parent-friendly guide to choosing between the two:
- Choose Kendamil Goat if: you want whole milk, no maltodextrin, a UK-sourced product, or an organic option.
- Choose Nannycare if: your baby has previously done well on Nannycare, you prefer a brand with 30+ years of heritage, or your health visitor has recommended it specifically.
- Not sure? Start with Kendamil Goat Stage 1 — it's our bestseller in this category and receives consistently strong feedback from parents.
🛒 Shop Goat Milk Formula Now — UK Stock, Fast Worldwide Shipping
Also Considering Cow's Milk Formula?
If you're also comparing goat formula to mainstream cow's milk options, our Aptamil range is one of the UK's most trusted formulas and is stocked in all stages. You may also find our in-depth Kendamil vs Aptamil comparison guide helpful — it's our most-read page and covers both brands in detail across all stages.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Kendamil Goat or Nannycare better for a sensitive tummy?
Both are commonly chosen by parents whose babies seem unsettled on cow's milk formula. Kendamil Goat's whole milk base and absence of maltodextrin makes it a popular first choice, but every baby is different. Always speak to your health visitor before switching.
Can I switch between Kendamil Goat and Nannycare?
It's generally best to stick with one formula once your baby is settled. If you do need to switch, transition gradually over 5–7 days by mixing increasing proportions of the new formula with the old.
Are both formulas available in the UK?
Yes — we stock both Kendamil Goat and Nannycare with UK-fresh stock and fast worldwide shipping.
Is goat milk formula suitable from birth?
Yes — both Kendamil Goat Stage 1 and Nannycare Stage 1 are suitable from birth as a sole source of nutrition when breastfeeding is not possible or chosen.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult your GP, health visitor, or paediatrician before changing your baby's formula.